Luxury brands: Does sin-free equal failure?

by Urs E. Gattiker on 2012/01/22 · 12 comments 1,486 views

Share with your Xing contacts
Summary
Bentley, Bugatti, Chloé, Hermès and Vertu are masters in best-of-both-worlds marketing. We outline how to have your cake and eat it, too.

Who does not love sin-free seduction that allows someone to consume luxury goods without guilt, since part of the purchase price is donated to charity. The parvenus (from the Latin perveniō, meaning arrive or reach) – those affluent people who crave status – may use Vuitton’s distinctive LV monogram, since the more subtle details of a Hermès bag’s price tag may not be recognized by all.

Click on image to read FT article - Having luxury goods is no longer enough - you have to be a connoisseur.What sets these luxury brands apart is clever marketing that covers the product in fairy dust to accentuate the positive. This golden rule of advertising requires portraying the product in its best light.

You may ask why Lady Gaga cannot sell luxury goods… Well, she can and sometimes it even works, but predicting public taste remains as hazardous as ever, while enduring it is even more so.

1. Usability could be average

Recently a friend of mine bought a pocket calendar from Freitag, a hip Swiss brand that makes bags and accessories out of old tarpaulins. The pocket calendar smells of old tarpaulin, was expensive and does not measure up to other pocket calendars (features, etc.).

Nevertheless, since it is Freitag, it is covered in fairy dust that allows some people to justify spending that kind of money. Therefore, lack of features is not important - just having a product made of used tarpaulin makes it cool.

2. Features may differ

Click on image for get info from Vertu - the phone with concierge service - Nokia is selling the company.Nokia is known for its sturdy, user-friendly phones, but decided to start its own luxury brand. To tap into a niche mobile device market, Nokia launched one of the world’s most expensive mobile phones in 1998 (the price rivals luxury watches, around €250,000, and units typically contain precious metals).

The phone is sold in more than 60 countries, with the strongest following in Russia, Asia and the Middle East, and though the units are technologically modest, they reportedly delivered double-digit sales growth in 2010 – outperforming the rest of Nokia.

Clients also benefit from a concierge service that makes taxi and restaurant bookings, etc., all at the touch of a direct-dial button on the phone. Features are one thing, exclusive concierge service is what makes this product special.

3. Soul of the brand

Vertu’s luxury handset did not overlap with Nokia’s reliable mass-market device offerings that include Microsoft’s smartphone software, but this was not extended to Vertu handsets. Because Vertu fails to fit Nokia’s brand image, is has been put up for sale.

Volkswagen is another example of too many brands to keep straight, such as:

  • Bugatti, which produces 40 cars each year;
  • Lamborghini, with about 1300;
  • Bentley, at 5,000 units;
  • Porsche, with a respectable 97,000; and
  • Audi, which offers 1.3 million ‘luxury cars for the masses’.

How does Volkswagen ensure that these brands remain distinct?  Why should I pay more for an Audi when 60 percent of its components are found in a Volkswagen or Skoda at a far lower price?

Click on image for more about VW's sales, on track to sell 8 million vehicles in 2011 - vastly different brands.

Besides the challenge of differentiating in-house brands, social media sends your advertising campaigns beyond their intended geographical region. Unfortunately, humor fails to travel, as this video intended for pet and Star Wars lovers illustrates (Beth Kanter kindly explained the video’s cultural issues).

YouTube Preview Image

What do you think?

Nevertheless, we can leverage a luxury brand’s image, as Bugatti does in this video of a drag race between their Veyron and the Royal Air Force’s (RAF) Euro Fighter Typhoon jet. But does this help your brand? It certainly increases your brand’s exposure to different people, and the content travels well across cultural borders, so the video will likely be appreciated by the product’s target audience.

Click on image for YouTube video - takes time to load 5:47 min of tape, but then it gets incredibly interesting - BBC car show Top GEAR - Bugatti Veyron vs. Euro Fighter Typhoon Drag Race.

If you want to stay abreast of the latest trends and figure out how to make them work for you, join our 5,000+ subscribers – enter your email here.


 

Bottom line – take-aways

The above examples suggest three things to remember:

  1. Best-of-both-worlds marketing – have your cake and eat it, too: Louis Vuitton uses celebrities in its advertising campaigns whose fee goes to a worthy cause. Or jet to an exotic hot spot while off-setting your flight emissions with CO2 certificates… Sin-free seduction allows clients to enjoy the product without feeling guilty.
  2. Manage and leverage the brand’s image carefully: The Bugatti Veyron vs Euro Fighter Typhoon drag race is distinct, exclusive and exciting, even for non-car buffs. Getting the RAF to join the race was a bonus, enabling both brands’ support of each other’s efforts to be perceived as authentic and exclusive.
  3. Today’s game is being a connoisseur: Once your luxury watch is ready, visit the Swiss atelier where the watch is hand-made. Chat with the workman finishing your piece, while listening to a story about how the company has made watches for posh global citizens forever. What was once sold as a timepiece is now an artistic and engineering masterpiece.

Click on image for free sample - ComMetrics - benchmark your social media efforts - use our tool.Picasso said that art tells lies to help us see the truth. It seems luxury brands use sin-free seduction to realize a hefty profit. And yes, the logo on your handbag or sports car may say far more about your social status and aspirations than the brand name itself.

More resources on this topic:

- Google Me teams up with Louis Vuitton
- Difference between a data scientist and a data analyst
- Affluent consumers to increase travel spending in 2012
- Christmas and luxury brands
- Luxury brands and social media ROI
- Ferrari loses, WEF blunders as Asia soars
- 2011 trendwatch webinar: Luxury brands and social media ROI

TipSearch for more ComMetrics and CyTRAP sources on luxury, marketing and branding (click to query).

Questions

  1. What is your favorite luxury brand?
  2. How do they use social media smartly?

Please share your thoughts below (click to write)!

If you like this post, please share it with your friends.

TL:DR
@ComMetrics 2012 marketing trendwatch – Luxury brands: Does sin-free equal failure? | Tweet This

By the way, once your product is covered in fairy dust, all you need to do serious damage is one link in your supply chain (see video). OUCH!
YouTube Preview Image

What satisfies your customer?

by Urs E. Gattiker on 2012/01/15 · 31 comments 2,202 views

Share with your Xing contacts
Summary
Have you joined HSBC and IBM in using sentiment analysis? We discuss people’s 4 biggest mistakes.

Some time ago, I posted Sentiment analysis for online content: Honest?, and moderated a discussion about it in our Xing Social Media Monitoring group. This is another update in our 2012 marketing trend series.

1. Mother tongue – what mother tongue?

The biggest challenge for marketers is that people’s mother tongue is increasingly something other than the locally spoken language, and people also increasingly learn English as a second or third language to facilitate communication across borders. This means that at least 80 percent of those who read your English sales brochure have a different first language.

Accordingly, many of your readers may not be very familiar with the language, so they may fail to understand the nuances and complexities in the user guidelines you offer for your product (see Don’t forget the language factor).

In short: Your sentiment analysis software does not understand your local slang – and neither do many of your customers, trust me.

2. Humor and irony fall flat

Besides the innuendo I may fail to comprehend, humor tends to travel not at all.

One reason may be that we lack comprehension, plus, innuendos and black humor may even upset some people. What makes your British readers smile, may trigger a yawn from a Canadian or cause misunderstanding and upset a non-native speaker.

In short: Your sentiment analysis software cannot account for humour or irony when analyzing the meaning of text.

3. Risqué marketing

Click on image to view more - this is the least racy picture I found - Sex and caskets make for a more lively coffin market.Risqué marketing can certainly lift your profile, but beware.

Sex is how we got here and death is how we will leave, but these two facts of life are rarely comfortable together, especially not in countries like Poland and Italy, where the Catholic Church strongly influences public life.

Nevertheless, that has not stopped Polish coffin maker Lindner from copying their Italian counterpart CofaniFunebri‘s use of scantily clad models to advertise coffins (see 2012 version).

And yes, watching a Lindner video on YouTube is most certainly less interesting for many men than viewing the company’s calendar. For those who do not believe me, numbers do not lie: Lindner’s professional two-minute video about how it manufactures coffins has only 569 views after over 2.5 years, while millions viewed the images on both companies’ websites. Many also purchased the calendars, certainly helping to build brand recognition with male consumers across Europe.

YouTube Preview Image

Whatever we think, it appears that the male species likes to watch images of beautiful women. Remember Cebu Pacific Air’s dancing flight attendants? Just before its initial public offering, Cebu made a video about dancing flight attendants giving safety instructions that grabbed over 10 million views. A male version soon followed, but its 45,000 views seem paltry in comparison (see below).

YouTube Preview Image

Unfortunately, sentiment analysis fails to see these things in context. When I wrote a blog post entitled, Sex, Lies and Infographics, I was surprised to have the software on the hotel guest PC I was using prevent me from accessing the page – inappropriate content. I am pretty sure this blog post will also be blocked, because it uses the word sex.

In short: Your sentiment analysis software cannot distinguish between risqué marketing and porn or sexually inappropriate content.

4. Dishonest marketing: Tell me why

Click on image to visit - The 'first direct live' site has six widgets; 1 shows comments left on the site by users - see image here - another has live words about the bank retrieved from around the web.In Why Sentiment Doesn’t Matter – If You Don’t Know Why, the author’s basic message is that sentiment does not matter without knowing the reason behind it. I fully agree. Looking at HSBC subsidiary first direct’s website indicates things are even worse.

Tracking customers’ online views and opinions is wonderful, but using single positive or negative words (see right) to suggest we like or dislike something is ludicrous, or what I would call dishonest marketing.

The friendly support guy from the savings bank showed us why support and technical support are two different things.

Since the above sentence uses all the positive words as listed, except for ‘plus’, does that make it a positive statement?

Of course, if people are dissatisfied with my service I want to know why. Is it

a) the free coffee for those waiting in line is no longer available, or
b) the increased monthly account charges are too high?

In short: Your sentiment analysis software will do most of what you ask it to do. Nonetheless, without knowing why your clients said great things about your brand or product, how are you supposed to improve?

Article source – What satisfies your customer?

If you want to stay abreast of the latest trends and figure out how to make them work for you, join our 5,000+ subscribers.


 

Bottom line

Image - tweet by @ComMetrics | #Metrics #data: it's always important to remember that an absence of evidence is not evidence of absence | #quote #socialmediaSocial media monitoring can be used to determine how often a company is mentioned, but to help you improve, sentiment analysis must go beyond this.

Online views about your products’ performance as experienced by clients are important. Most companies will try to collect this information to ensure that future releases include these suggestions for improvement.

We agree with this marketing trend, but always remember:

  1. Focus on the why: If you use sentiment analysis, take the time and make the effort to understand the context, such as what sexy means in ‘sleek and sexy design’.
  2. Forget navel gazing metrics: In itself, having only 10 comments compared to your client’s 222 does not mean you are doing badly – you must analyze these comments to understand whether they represent engagement or just opinions.

More resources on this topic
ComMetrics - benchmark your social media efforts - use the tools that help Nike, Coca-Cola and Daimler IMPROVE.

Kommboutique - Why Twitter is not Facebook is not LinkedIn… and how to use them right for business!
Claudia Thomas - Test & Tutorial ‘Google Alerts’ and Test & Tutorial ‘Social Mention’
ComMetrics weekly review – sentiment analysis in social media
ComMetrics weekly review: IBM to SPSS and stats in social media
ComMetrics - Using semantic analysis to identify smear tactics on Twitter
Goldbach Interactive - Best Performer Tools in Social-Media-Monitoring: Report 2011

Start here to learn how to walk the walk and measure for impact – it’s the quickest way to empower change.

Tip: Search for ComMetrics and CyTRAP sources on sentiment analysis, KPI, strategy and reputation management (click to query).

Please share your thoughts with a comment below!

TL:DR
@ComMetrics 2012 marketing trendwatch: What satisfies your customer? | Tweet This